Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Ladder Challenge: Brady vs Williams

In the last edition of Ladder Challenge it was John Hannah edging Dit Clapper with 53% of the vote to allow the greatest guard in NFL history to stay at #11 on the Ladder. In this week's Challenge it is features two of the best in Boston sports history as #5 Ted Williams attempts to move up a spot by knocking off #4 Tom Brady. Our vote, an incredibly tough one, is for Brady, who has combined personal excellence with team success, while Teddy Ballgame was never able to bring home a title despite his amazing individual achievements. So who has your support in this week's Ladder Challenge? (and remember, most votes in the comments section is the tie-breaker, so be sure to voice your opinion!)

7 comments:

DK said...

TOM BRADY
Currently Ranked: 4
Challenge Record: 0-2-0
Beat: Nobody
Lost: Bobby Orr, Larry Bird
Tied: Nobody
-------------------------------------------------
*Has played entire 10-year career (2000-09) with the Patriots.

*Won 3 Super Bowls (2001, 2003, 2004).

*Won 2 Super Bowl MVP Awards (2001, 2003).

*Selected to 4 Pro Bowls.

*Named All Pro 2 times.

*2007 NFL MVP.

*2007 NFL Player of the Year.

*2007 NFL Offensive Player of the Year.

*2007 AP Male Athlete of the Year.

*2-time Sporting News Sportsman of the Year (2004, 2007).

*Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year (2005).

*Led Pats to only 16-0 season in NFL history (2007).

*Career totals: 86-24 record; 2301-3653 (63.0%), 26,446 yards, 197 TD, 86 INT, 92.9 QB Rating.

*Career playoff totals: 14-3 record; 372-595 (62.5%), 3,954 yards, 26 TD, 12 INT, 88.0 QB Rating.

*Led league in: Passing Yards and Passing TD twice each.

*Led league in: QB Rating, Passing Yards per Game, Passing Yards per Attempt, Completion %, and TD % once each.

*Franchise all-time records (for QB) for: Wins (87), Completion % (63.0), TD Passes (197) and QB Rating (92.9).

*Also ranks in Patriots all-time TOp 10 (for QB) in: Completions (2), Attempts (2), Passing Yards (3) and Games (3).

*Franchise Single-Season records: Wins (16, 2007), Completion % (68.9, 2007), Yards (4,806, 2007), TD Passes (50, 2007), TD % (8.7, 2007), QB Rating (117.2, 2007).

*NFL Records: Most TD passes in a season (50, 2007), Highest TD/Interception differential (+42, 2007), Most consecutive post-season win for a QB (10), Most completions in a Super Bowl (32, SB XXXVIII), Most career Super Bowl completions (100), Highest playoff completion % for a single game (92.9%, 26/28, vs Jax in 2007).

DK said...

TED WILLIAMS
Currently Ranked: 5
Challenge Record: 0-0-1
Beat: Nobody
Lost: Nobody
Tied: Larry Bird
-------------------------------------------------
*Played entire 19-year career (1939-42, 46-60) with the Red Sox.

*Won 1946 A.L. Championship.

*Named AL MVP twice (1946, 1949).

*Named MLB Player of the Year by The Sporting News 5 times (1941-42, 1947, 1949, 1957).

*Won Triple Crown twice (1942, 1947).

*Selected to 17 AL All Star teams.

*Hit walk-off HR in bottom of the 9th of 1941 All Star Game.

*All Star MVP Award is now named in his honor.

*Led the American League in batting average (6x), on-base % (12x), slugging % (9x), OPS (10x), runs (6x), total bases (6x), home runs (4x), runs batted in (4x), walks (8x), extra-base hits (5x) and times on base (8x).

*Career statistics: .344 BA, .482 OBP, .634 SLG, 1.116 OPS, 521 HR, 1,839 RBI and 1,798 runs scored.

*Had 2,021 BB and just 709 K.

*Franchise career leader in BA, OBP, SLG, OPS, HR and BB.

*Franchise single-season records in BA, OBP, SLG, OPS, BB, Intentional BB, runs and times on-base.

*ML record for career on-base percentage.

*Last player to hit over .400 in a season (.406, 1941).

*Named to MLB All-Century Team.

*Elected to Baseball Hall of Fame (1968).

*His #9 is retired by the Red Sox.

DK said...

I find anyone in the Top 5 pretty difficult to vote against, so along with the titles I think the challenger has to clearly deserve the win...and this one is too close to knock off Brady in my book.

Luke said...

Ted Williams.

Sean said...

Brady

Walpole Joe said...

It is a tight race, but I think Brady by a head.

DuffMan said...

I'm going with "The Kid". Greatest hitter who ever lived and he served in two wars.

I don't even think it would be an arguement if he had won a couple of World Series, but a lot depends on your teamates and it didn't help that the Yankess were in the same division.